Wednesday, March 29, 2017

Korne Daemonkin or Warband?



Over the past year I have been collecting a Khorne Daemonkin army, but the new Traitor Legions book has given me a new way to represent my force. A World Eaters warband has some exciting new rules, but how do they compare the the Khorne Daemonkin?



Formations:
IMG_9188.jpgWorld Eaters use the Chaos Warband and Maelstrom of Blood as their main two formations, and both of them are fantastic. The Chaos Warband has a host of great units without any real “tax” of less than desireable ones. Alternatively, the Maelstrom of Blood lets you take a ton of berzerkers that, in this formation, become some of the fastest infantry in the game.


Daemonkin have their classic formation that gives you the option to take bloodletters rather than marines or berzerkers. The downside is that you must take one squad of possessed. Many of the secondary formations are great, but they can’t get objective secured units unless you take a combined arms detachment.


My vote here goes to the World Eaters, since the Daemonkin still suffer from a unit tax.

Objective Grabbing:
The overall ‘decurion’ formation for World Eaters gives all non-vehicles a 2d6 move before the start of the game. This can be helpful for moving on objectives early.


One of the biggest advantages of Daemonkin is their ability to summon new units. Not being able to charge the turn they are summoned means that they are perfect for capturing objectives.


The winner here is clearly the Daemonkin. Deep striking units are incredible for going after objectives, and summoning new units makes it that much better.

Offense:
IMG_9112.JPGWorld Eaters bonuses make them an incredibly fast army. Up until this point, turn two charges were the goal.  Now turn one charges are actually a possibility, and turn two charges become even more likely. Units like bikes, raptors, and spawn end up with an 89% chance of making a turn one charge against an opponent that is 24” away, and a 26% chance against units that are 30” away. Regular infantry also gained some massive mobility and end up with a 65% chance of making a turn two charge at 30”.


Daemonkin have some fast units, but nothing capable of making a turn one charge. The tradeoff is that the more units you kill with a Daemonkin army, the stronger your army becomes. Summoning new units throughout the game means that you continue to apply pressure to your opponent without losing steam.

IMG_9169.jpgThere isn’t as clear of a winner here. Depending on your preferred play style, you might work better with an ‘alpha strike’ type of list that the World Eaters offer. Despite the early movement, the Khorne warband still has a difficult time catching fast units. The Daemonkin can also cause massive carnage, but will see their advantages spread more evenly over the course of the game.

Defense:
World Eaters all gain “fearless,” which doesn’t make them less likely to die from a bolter round, but it does mean that the squad isn’t going to run at the first sight of blood. This one change is a massive improvement in the staying power of an army.


One of the best choices on Daemonkin’s blood tithe is giving “feel no pain” to your whole army. Combine this with consistent invulnerable saves for daemons, and you have a force that isn’t easy to remove. Daemons also come with “fearless,” but the marines still have to worry about leadership.


Daemonkin take the cake here. Daemons come with “fearless” and an invulnerable save naturally. With so many big guns on the battlefield, power armor just isn’t what it used to be. Throw in “feel no pain” and the winner is clear.


Overall:
The new World Eaters are good; I would expect to see them performing well in tournaments. Their ability to move large blocks of infantry across the board mean that horde-style armies could come back into play. If you want to ally in daemons, you can use formations like the Carnal Cohort to gain some of the advantages of the blood tithe system. Fortunately, there is a ton of overlap between the units in World Eaters and Daemonkin. For the most part, everything can just move right over.


4 comments:

  1. Why choose? The models can be flip flopped back and forth to whatever you want (a flesh hound is a flesh hound). I was just inspired when I got murdered by a bunch of said hounds on my psykers to make my own Khorne list to use against my arch nemesis. A foe that always spams scatbikes, brings WK, and seer council. My list in a few weeks will be:

    Primary Detachment Daemon Incursion
    Khorne murderhorde
    HoK on jugger with crown (warlord)
    8x units of MSU hounds
    Karanak auxiliary

    base Gorepack (melta bombs on biker champs) just to get some tithe swings in. What happens if a gorepack and all of these regular hounds are in the same combat and wipe a unit... I still get blood tithe points?

    World Eaters warband
    Lord on hound with AoBF (goes with gorepack hounds but can move around)
    2x msu marines on foot
    msu terminators with axes
    bikers (fist on champ)
    havocs with AC
    khorne spawn auxiliary

    That is a lot of fearless bodies scouting all over the field corrupting objectives and securing them too. 1820 points still room for 30 points of wargear (if only that lord could also wield talisman of blood!). I play a lot of maelstrom, and find having massive amounts models that can move around is the best way to scoring these points. Now it is time to see how killy 45 flesh hounds + bolter spam can be?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think it would cost more than the 30 points you have leftover, but you can change out the AoBF with a LC/PF combo and then take the Talisman. Given that he has a MoK and a jugger, the lord is going to get a million attacks even without the daemon axe (and without the chance to wound himself 1/6 of the time).

      Delete
    2. I think I can make that work Threllen! Good catch. While I want to love daemon weapons the past month has literally lost me games because of them (1 in both of turn 2's combat phases while challenging solitaire with my DG biker lord).

      Delete
    3. Yeah, I love the AoBF for the full initiative AP2, but I've screwed myself with daemon weapons so many times in the past. Rolling that 1 is a scary prospect...

      Delete